Believe you me, poppets, I spent some time thinking long and hard about whether I was going to bother recapping The Fashion Show, Bravo's new fashion oriented reality competition program which is
in no way a rip off of Project Runway,
not at all, absolutely not.
I mean, in the first place, do I really want to invest in another Bravo program when I still have a few weeks left of
Make Me a Supermodel, and nothing could possibly give me more joy than another few weeks of hot, British, occasionally naked Jonathan? And then the
Real Housewives of New Jersey starts soon, and I'm beyond fascinated by the absolute Guidoness of these women. I mean, you could have driven to Ellis Island and picked up my great grandfather when he was getting off the boat from Calabria, and he would've been less Guido than these women.
And in the second place, I'm kind of angry at Bravo, for reasons that are best left unsaid, but if I were a generation older and the sort of person who did that sort of thing, I might call them a horrible politically incorrect name that rhymes with Schmindian Schmivers.
But on the other hand, there are still months and months until Lifetime finally unlooses the long-since-wrapped Sixth Season of
Project Runway. Long, dull months with nothing to do but sit out the humidity in my basement apartment listening to my hair get bigger and bigger by the second.

And then I saw him.
His name is Merlin. I kind of want to adopt him, and keep him in my closet, where I'll never have to see him or speak to him, because who am I kidding? In person, he'd be the worst thing ever.
So anyway, I'm in. . . at least for now. Be prepared for this one to be sparse, though. I'm cat sitting, and while the cats finally have cable (yay!) they have some sort of insane Verizon cable and I don't understand the remote control at all, so I can't pause and rewind and things.
And away we go!
New York! Issac Mizrahi voice-overs about finding 15 talented designers to create fashion for us. Kelly Rowland is also there, being incredibly wooden. They explain the basics of the competition--the designers will be judged by them, Fern Mallis, and a guest judge; win $125K provided by Tresemme, and see the winning pieces produced and available for sale on Bravo. Yeah, this is
absolutely nothing like
Project Runway.
Ok, so the one way it's not is that
WE get to decide who the winner is. I'm not at all excited about this. The heartbreak of this week's
Dancing With the Stars has taught me not to trust the opinion and taste of the American public. You know what the American Public will get you? They'll get you a rodeo cowboy who dances with an iron pole up his ass staying over Li'l Kim. Li'l
freaking Kim, y'all.
The credits show each of the designers in the pages of a faux magazine. There are a number of them, and they all have ridiculous names like Haven and Reco. Oh, and Merlin. Lest we forget. Anyway, the designers, in order of introduction, are:
Kristen: from Chicago; has
JEM hair and makes organic clothes
James-Paul: Postcolonialist designer; has worked for Vivienne Westwood
Merlin: Has a red cape and a matching peter pan hat. And is Merlin. Lest we forget.
Lidia: Avant Garde
Reco: designed for strippers to pay his way through college. This is AWESOME. This is like chicks who strip to pay for college, but requiring actual talent.
Kristen asks if Merlin knows any magic tricks. He says "I disappear people one by one." Ha-ha.
Jonny D: men's wear
Laura: Eco-friendly designer
Keith: evening wear
Johnny: Modern Streetwear designer and fashion school drop out
Haven: 80's inspired. I wonder if Haven is her birth name--if so, it validates my theory that your name is your destiny, because Haven is totally a name that no one except the teen vixen on an '80's soap should ever be cursed with.
Markus: went to "best fashion school in world"
Anna: from Brooklyn
Angel: experimental; works with heat sensitive inks. So. . . it's like those
Hypercolor shirts or what?
Daniella: ready to wear designer
Andrew: men's underwear designer. Yes, please. Apparently a lot of people know him as
"the panty Christ." I went to high school with a girl who was afraid of the word "panties"--she would scream and freak out if you even said it. We all hated her, so we used to have our 6'4" red-haired pink-skinned friend chase her around chanting "panties, panties, panties." It was the creepiest thing ever. Those were good times.
Um, anyway, the point of that little digression, in as much as there's ever a point to my little digressions, is that she would've been
terrified of the Panty Christ. Which is how we shall always refer to Andrew.
Issac and Kelly enter and everyone claps. Issac says the competition is about creativity,

construction, saleability and wearability.
Now they'll have their 1st Harper's Bazaar Mini Challenge, which is like a quick fire, but with clothing. It's a clothfire.
Kelly tells us "I have worn over 100 little black dresses in my day." Isaac says they have an hour to make a little black dress. . .. out of a black t-shirt.
Fashion Flurry! we see them making all their dresses, and guess what--there are 15 of them and I'm not going to be able to discuss them all. Anyway, at some point, Merlin leaves his boots (white thigh high go go boots) on a machine to mark his turf and Anna steals it.
The judge for the Mini Challenge is Laura Brown from Harper's Bazaar. She calls Reco's out as a stripper's dress, but a good one; says Johnny's has airbags built in; compliments Keith's and Merlin's and hates the garment bag on James Paul's. The three top are Merlin, Keith, and. . . .some large guy with a bun on top of his head. Oh, that's Johnny. After the airbag comment? Huh.
The elimination challenge is in teams. The three winners will be the heads of the teams. Merlin gives an interview wearing the rat-hat from Seinfeld about how he doesn't want to work in teams.
Commercial!
Back! Each of the head designers gets to choose their design team, and they choose based on dress rather than names. And I would try and tell you who was on which team, but really, there are so many of them and it goes on for so long and all you really know is that Reco is the first one chosen (by Johnny) and Lidia is the last (and goes with Merlin)
Elimination challenge. Isaac tells them that every season, his design team has to think of "must have" pieces. Each team must create one "must have" garment and design five different looks around it. Each designer will create a copy of the must have piece and the look to go with it. The 5 looks must create a cohesive collection. They have two hours that night and eleven hours the next day.
Just to impress this on you: this is
nothing like the challenge from Season 4 of
Project Runway where they had to choose an iconic look (like overalls) and working in teams design a small collection that updated that look.
Johnny's team comes up with harem pants, which Reco informs us is "a couture name for
Hammer pants." Under whatever name, I can't think of a single situation in which I must have harem pants.
Ok, maybe if I ever manage to whip together my long planned Evil Jeannie Halloween costume. But that's the only time.
Keith's team is going with a sexy pencil skirt that can be worn as a strapless dress. THAT? Could be a a must have.
Merlin's team decides on a bolero jacket in navy.
They go to B&J fabrics which is
NOT AT ALL LIKE when they go to Mood on
Project Runway.
Merlin and Daniella fight over whether the bolero jacket should be navy, with him insisting that he's the leader and her insisting that she knows whats in fashion right now. Daniela wins, and Merlin checks out with his navy fabric saying "eez going look like eez for an ol' lady." Wuss.
They work for two hours and then go to their digs at
Le Parker Meridien, where they're sleeping in wooden bunk beds. Seriously, it looks like a dorm. Or every apartment the
Project Runway contestants ever lived in. Commercial!
Back. Merlin dances around their apartment in his briefs and dress shirt/tie with a goblet of wine. Someone makes a comment about his "man berries." Argh. That was the short scene. I continue to hate the short scenes.
Ok, finally back. Morning in New York. The Fashion show is in one day. Haven recaps what their team is doing with their harem pants. They're doing. . .as much as one can do with harem pants. Haven admits to not being good at sewing. Reco is making a jacket with a neat collar.

Merlin's team has more drama over the jacket, with Merlin calling it "dee mose seemple, datted piece I seen in my life."
Team tube skirt is concerned about Jonny D, who appears to have dressed his form in a business skirt and satin nipple covers. Oh, that's supposed to be a Marilyn Monroe inspired halter top. Huh.
Issaac and Kelly come through for their version of the Tim through/Tom through. They tell the designers that every fashion show will be in front of a live audience of buyers and fashion insiders who will vote on their looks. The winning look will be made and sold online.
Isaac points out--gently--how odd it is to have a grey satin harem pant as a "must have," and then they go around pointing out less gently how crappy all the sewing is on many of the looks.
At team Merlin, they discuss the bolero jacket more. Merlin's is kind of cute for a playsuit; James Paul has a muslin sack.
Team Keith describes their skirt/dress. Kelly and Isaac freak out over how tight the skirt is, and Kelly brilliantly says "I need some butter and a miracle to put that on me." Ha! I kind of love Kelly already, despite her initial woodenness and the absolute W-T-F-ery of having her in what I can't stop thinking of as Heidi Klum's role.
Kristen then completely sells out her team as not having good communication.
Kelly and Isaac leave the workroom giggling deviously, and gossip in the hallway about the teams. It's kind of unsettling--like if Tom Colicchio gave his mean opinions in the company of a girl who does nothing but giggle and agree. Kelly is wearing a cocktail ring that you could use as a tea saucer. I fucking covet it. Kristen's team calls her out for her bitchassedness in selling them out. Commercial!
Back! Day of Fashion show! everyone gets dressed in their little dorm style apartment. Holy god, there's another 45 minutes of this nonsense left.
The models get ready while the stylists name drop Tresemme awkwardly. "Hey, Katie, can I have the Tresemme shine spray please." Ok, this really
is nothing like
Project Runway--it's more like the first season of
Top Chef where Harold had to be all "and then we went back to the townhouse and had a barbecue using our Kingsford Briquettes, and a nice salad with some Hidden Valley Ranch dressing."
The guest judge is
Ellie Tahari, whose line was featured on
Make Me a Supermodel recently. He must have a deal with Bravo.
Johnny's team goes first. Reco's design is cute-ish--there's a limit to how enthused I can be over purple satin harem pants. Some girl's design looks like a sloppy version of Recos with a lot of ruching at the waist. Johnny's design is "athletic"--which means it's a pouffed sleeve crop top with the pants, which, oddly, is
exactly what I wear to work out. Haven's is a short sleeved crop top with the pants. Markus has a sheer top with the pants. This team fucking sucks. Harem pants FAIL.
Kristen is first with team Keith, and her design is odd and badly proportioned and styled like crap. Jonny D's is just

cheap and awful. Keith's is cute, but too short and too tight. Anna's . . .is good--the skirt is a dress with a red bolero over it. I'd wear it if the dress were a different fabric and longer and not as tight. Panty Christ's dress looks good.
Team Merlin! Daniella's is stark and kind of awful. Merlin's is a playsuit, which I would never wear myself, but it's freaking cute. Angel's looks like a stewardess from the 60's. James Paul's is a sack with some angles. Lidia's has a collar that will eat her head and an awful skirt.
Wow. . .so much suckage. I realize that they're supposed to do more "realistic" challenges in this show, but I've been more impressed with first episode
Project Runway challenges where they had 20 minutes to make a ballgown out of orange rinds and crap than I am with this shit.
We get reactions from the audience, which I largely disagree with, because some of them are actually positive. These people are freaking liars--there's nothing good to be said about this mess. They should sack up and acknowledge this. It would make the show a lot more interesting
Isaac congratulates them for completing the first show. Kelly tells them that in the whole show "there was not one must have piece. . .that I care to have." YES! Thank you, girl. Commercial!
Back. Isaac tells them they need to hear criticism.
Fern loves the ideas of their items, but the execution was poor. Isaac was embarrassed and would fire them all if they worked for him. He knows they're capable of more, and they've let him down.
Johnny's team is safe, and can take a seat. Um. . .what? They made shiny harem pants.
Merlin's team is the winning team. They're all excited, except Daniella who's scowling, and then there's a poor attempt at drama, and Isaac tells them to communicate without offending each

other.
The two looks that stood out were James-Paul's dress and Merlin's playsuit. Isaac says the bolero is at its best with the playsuit. James Paul talks about squares and rectangles and creating volume. Fern likes the black/navy combo. Isaac tells them that the winner is. . . .James-Paul. WHAT???? Is. . .what???????? Jesus Christ, this is like fucking bizarro world.
Merlin's team gets to sit down.
So, clearly team pencil skirt is the losing team, and someone's going home. Isaac tells them the idea was good, but the execution was poor. Kelly points out that if the skinny models can't wear the skirt, no human can.
The bottom two looks are Kristen's, where they want to know what the designer was thinking and called it bargain basement. Fern points out that you can't see the must-have, and the styling is poor.
The audience called Jonny D's outfit slutty. Isaac points out that it's "breast centric." I'm going to refer to things as 'breast centric" from now on. Oooh.. .apparently the model had to be cut out of her skirt to go to the bathroom.
Deliberation. Rather than sending the designers away, the judges go and huddle back stage. Again, there's some weirdness here that makes it very different from other Bravo shows. . .and not in a good way, necessarily. It seems really furtive and mean, like they're saying shit behind the designers' backs. Which. . .yeah, they're doing, and they do on every show, but the fact that

they go creeping off just emphasizes that. Commercial!
Back. Kelly says that one of them is going home tonight.
Isaac says that Jonny picked a "woman glorifying design" and made it look terrible. In Isaac's world, "glorifying" and "skankifying" are synonyms.
Kristen's look was unfocused, and he wonders if she should be in this business.
Then he tells Jonny "we're just not buying it. Bye-bye darling." Jonny leaves. Kelly tells Kristen that she's still in, but she's hanging by a thread. Multiple catch phrase FAIL.

Jonny packs his design in a garment bag and cries. Which is
totally different from
Project Runway, where the designers put their losing design on the dress form and cry.
This season: bleed for fashion! don't insult us! Daniella continues to be a bitch. Lots of crying. Reco looks oddly like Dave Chapelle.
And. .. a lot of other stuff designed to convince us this show is not just a rip off of
Project Runway. No way. Not at all. Why would you even think such a thing?