
One fish, Ari Fish
Geodesic silver dress?
I question your taste.
So first, I know I said I wasn’t going to recap the All Star Challenge, and I’m standing by that. But I will say that I thought it was utter bullshit. Daniel V.’s collection should’ve been in the bottom (I mean seriously? It was almost as trashy and awful as Santino’s. One girl had a bright blue zipper running directly up her ass crack on her skintight black mini skirt), and the only reason I can think of for them to hand him that win is because they want to be perceived as righting a previous wrong. . . a wrong done by BRAVO. The new shiny (poorer film quality) Lifetime Project Runway can swoop in and give the win to one of the all time favorite Bravo also rans, win over any fans who still give a crap about things that happened in Season 2, and stick it to the exes.
But enough about that. On with the main event.

Los Angeles! Yikes, Los Angeles? Yep! The designers start arriving at their product placement apartments, and we get to know a few of them.
Ra’Mon: from Chicago; dropped out of Med school to pursue fashion. Reminds me of Shemar Moore in
Diary of a Mad Black Woman, so like everything that reminds me of that awful, awful movie, I immediately hate him.
Logan: from Seattle, a guy’s guy.
Johnny: a recovering Crystal Meth addict. If you forget that for a moment, you’ll be reminded like 97 times over the course of the next hour. In fact, let’s
drink every time Johnny reminds us that he’s an addict.
Gordana: “Eef you geeve me a sheep, I can make a sweater.” From former Yugoslavia.
Malvin: Looks kind of like an Asian Michael Jackson
Carol Hannah: young blonde thing.
Qristyl: spells crystal with a Q and a y, and designs “plus sexy” clothing
Shirin: her name means “sweet in Farsi,” and she looks just adorbs. Does multifunctional clothing.
Nicolas: known as the “feather prince.” I hate him within seconds. He’s like Jeffery and Kayne had a bastard love child together, rolled him in a giant vat of smug, and then sent him to Christian for ego training.
Mitchell: such a cute little button.
Epperson: 49
Christopher: from Minnesota.
Ari: tries to channel her creative side by asking “hello, fabric, what would you like me to make you into today?” By the end of the episode, her fabric is screaming “not this, you crazy bitch! Not this!!!!”
Althea: another young blonde thing
Irina: designs totes inspired by her poodle, Princess, who growls at the camera.
Louise: flapper wannabe. I love her already.
Malvin says he’s surprised that they’re not in New York, but Johnny the addict says that L.A.’s fashion district is much bigger. Meanwhile, Carol Hannah and Gordana have met in the past.
The designers chat and get to know each other, and we get a little more info about some of the ones with briefer intros. Then they get the ubiquitous note from Heidi inviting them to join her and Tim on the roof.

Heidi welcomes them to Los Angeles and introduces Tim. Hi Tim! Tim says they’re the 16 who’ve proven they have the talent and passion to be there out of the 1000s they considered, and tells them about where they’ll be working and so forth.
Then they mingle and do some more getting to know you stuff. Included in this are segments where Louise tells us she’s inspired by vintage and Malvin says he’s androgynous. Once again, hello, captains obvious.
We also learn that Althea is hopelessly young, and that Christopher is self taught. We’ll hear that another 87 times this hour. Let’s drink every time we hear about him being self taught, too.
Heidi tells them it’s time for the party to end and the work to begin. But not just yet, though, not like season 3 where they had to immediately go downstairs and destroy their apartment for materials. They get to sleep and then meet Tim the next morning at an undisclosed location.
Which they do. . . on the red carpet for the 60th annual prime time Emmys at the Nokia

theatre. So this was filmed . . . .
how long ago?
Tim tells them that their first challenge is to create a red carpet look that demonstrates true innovation and conveys their vision as designers. It can be any red carpet—Oscars, Emmys, VMA awards. . .et endless cetera, since there are about 6 million red carpet events per year. The designers are excited.
And really, who wouldn’t be? It’s kind of a cakewalk of a first challenge. It’s certainly not comparable to making things out of your furniture, or things you find at a grocery store. Make a dress that expresses your vision. That’s what these people do.
So they head to their FIDM workroom to check out their fancy west coast digs. Their models have been preassigned for this challenge. Ari is excited that her model has “big feet like me.” Tim’s response is a bewildered “. . .yeah!” I concur with Tim, as usual. You’re not designing shoes, space cadet.
They’ll have 30 minutes to sketch, and then a budget of $200 and 30 minutes to shop at Mood. They have until midnight tonight and all the next day to work, and the winner will have immunity for the next challenge.
They sketch. Christopher is doing something with texture. Malvin assures us that he doesn’t “differentiate between different colored carpets.” Oh, Jesus, how fucking pretentious can you be in the first half hour? He’s carpet color blind! Malvin has a dream that some day, the sons of red carpets and the sons of hand hooked Navajo rugs can lay down together on the great floor of brotherhood.
Ari doesn’t sketch. She just meditates on the mood of the garment. She apparently does this upsidedown. It's really bizarre.

Mood! 30 minutes to shop! They all tear about madly. Ari is going for “bulbous hexagonal tessalation forms that catch the light.” Qristyl with a Q wants to cut her fabric herself since there’s only one guy cutting. Time! Thank you, Mood!
Back at the workroom, Tim reminds them that innovation is key. Shemar Moore Ra’Mon does the first crying interview of the season. Mitchell is smocking, and Christopher doesn’t know what smocking means, because he’s self taught!
DRINK! Johnny is second guessing himself because “coming from an addiction standpoint”
DRINK! He can’t handle stressful situations without a support structure, and he

feels lost and overwhelmed.
Johnny goes off to a lounge to cry, and Ra’Mon and various other people let him talk at them. Johnny kind of wants to throw in the towel. Well, let him. Hearing about his addiction this much is damaging to my sobriety.
Commercial!
Back! We continue working at FIDM. Johnny continues crying in the painfully red lounge, and tells us that “coming out of an addiction is hard. “
DRINK! He wants to leave, but Tim comes to talk to him about not being to hard on himself. Johnny says “coming through all the drugs and everything”
DRINK! And then he sobs more. He just doesn’t want to fail again, and feels unready for the experience. Tim says he’s overcome SO MUCH, and that he believes in him.

Johnny talks about how it feels to have Tim Gunn talk you through something, and how he really makes you feel like he wants you to succeed, no matter what. I want my own little Tim Gunn to talk me through things! He can live in the closet with
Laura (and the
espiders) and come out and give me a pep talk every time I need one.
Back to work! There’s more of the usual stuff about their dresses. They leave, and go back to the apartments.
The next morning, Johnny is feeling a lot better about things. They go back to FIDM. Gordana and Christopher talk about how they wish they’d been able to go to design school.
DRINK!

Tim through! He cautions Christopher to style his dress correctly (using the Macy’s accessory wall), and asks about Ari’s “geodesic dome.” Ari’s dress will be “a halter dress with a large hood” and Tim worries that it could become “a halter diaper.”
Mitchell adorably calls Tim “Mr. Gunn” and shows him the weird Miss Havisham number he’s making. Qristyl with a Q asks Tim if her dress is “dramatic in a good way to you?” and Tim LITERALLY stands there with his MOUTH OPEN in that weird “start to speak and then try to convert it to an inhalation because I’m at a loss for words” thing you do when you totally can’t think of anything nice to say so want to stop yourself from saying anything at all.
He covers by saying to ask
herself that, not him. He sends in the models. Did anyone watch
Models of the Runway? I haven’t. . .yet.
Mitchell’s model’s sizes are all wrong, so he has to rework everything. Poor little lamb. They have until midnight to finish, and mere nanoseconds tomorrow. All Mitchell is left with after his fitting mishap is his horrible Miss Havisham collar. Really, that would’ve been the first thing to go if I found myself in his shoes. Commercial!
Back! Day of Runway show! The designers get ready and then head to FIDM. There are still too many of them for me to take an interest in their interpersonal conversations.
Qristyl with a Q is nervous, but feels confident. Mitchell is reworking EVERYTHING, but the only fabric he has leftover is “very very similar to pantyhose.”
Tim enters. They have two hours to send their models through the product placement hair and makeup studios, and use the product placement accessory walls. Mitchell is stitching his model into the pantyhose dress. Nicolas says “he’s basically sending a NUDE model down the runway.” For someone who’s made a career out of building those shitty wings for the Victoria’s Secret Fashion show, Nicolas sounds oddly scandalized at the prospect of a NUDE model.
Mitchell explains what he’s doing to Christopher and asks if that sounds like a good plan. “I think it sounds like a plan,” Christopher hedges beautifully. So skilled! He’s clearly not self-taught in the tact department.
The models go through hair and makeup. Tim tells them they have 10 more minutes. And then it’s time! They head out.
Commercial!

Back! Runway! Heidi appears and reminds them that one day they’re in. . . and the next day. . . they’re out. She reminds them about the challenge, and introduces the judges.
God, I’ve missed introducing the judges SO MUCH! First we have Orange American Designer, Michael Kors! Now with Marie Claire Magazine, Nina Garcia! And a judge who’s spent a lot of time on the red carpet. . . .and even

more collapsed on the bathroom floor. . . .Lindsay Lohan!
She looks so cute. So this was filmed back when she was sober, right?
Let’s start the runway!
Althea’s dress is a fairly ordinary looking silver thing. Gordana’s is a Tiffany blue cocktail dress with some geometric shapes around the bust. Malvin’s is a linen-looking dress that seems ordinary, but has some interesting details on the back and in the texture.
Still, it’s not exactly red carpet.
It’s a far sight better than Mitchell’s, though. Mitchell's looks like Lovey Howell’s nightie, but rendered entirely in pantyhose fabric. Seriously, it’s likd he put a collar on a tablecloth.
Louise’s is a metallic ‘30’s looking number. Christophers is such fun—black and grayish pink and full of ruffles and texture. Ra’Mon’s is a basic purple gown with one shoulder and a neat squared off train.
Shirin’s is kind of a champagne colored Audrey Hepburn number. Epperton’s is too black and too overwhelming. Irina’s is a beautiful gold dress with a black belt.
And then there’s Ari’s which is her geodesic dome top with purple hot pants. It's just dreadful. Her model is gorgeous, though. I hope someone else snaps her up. Maybe Mitchell can take her since he probably won't want to stay with his giantess.
Johnny’s is a red dress that’s kind of a halter, and has interesting shapes. Carol Hannah’s is gold with a structured bodice. Qristyl with a Q’s is purple with a joosh of cruise wear fabric going down the front. Logan’s is a long silver dress with an asymmetric bodice. Finally, Nicolas’s is a

crappy looking black thing with some texture on the bodice.
Heidi sends away pretty much everyone, because it’s that early in the game. Left standing: Mitchell, Qristyl with a Q, Ari, Johnny, Ra’Mon, and Christopher.
Qristyl with a Q says her girl is going to the Emmys, and she can see Lindsay or Miley wearing it. Lindsay gives very sound criticism about how the back is great but the front is awful. Wow, Lindsay Lohan sounds SMART, y’all. Someone needs to keep this girl’s shit together like Jamie Spears does for Britney, and then she’ll have an amazing career.
Christopher’s model is heading for the VMA’s. Heidi likes the dress, but not the softer color. Michael Kors wrote “cute and edgy” as his critique. Nina likes the dark, romantic attitude, and Lindsay thinks it needs less ruffles, but she likes it.
Ramon’s gown is for the Oscars. Heidi likes it a lot. Kors finds it chic and well made, but thinks it needs to be pumped up a bit. Lindsay concurs that it’s a bit safe.
Ari’s girl is going to “the VMA’s, like 2080.” And she’s going to receive her Nobel Peace prize on the same night. Kors is having none of this, and tells her the model looks like “a disco soccer ball,” and that there’s no beauty in the piece. Lindsay respects the fact that she has her own ideas, but thinks she’s not aware of what’s acceptable for the context. OH MY GOD, Lindsay Lohan is like the best guest judge ever.
Johnny’s was inspired by a 20’s starlet, and he wanted it to feel languid. Nina says it’s “wonderful and easy.” Lindsay doesn’t care for the color, but Kors adds that the dress is so interesting that he doesn’t need an interesting color at all.
Mitchell explains his model sizing debacle, and Heidi reminds him that models LIE. Nina says it’s “completely sheer and completely unwearable,” but has an attitude she likes. Kors says it looks whipped together, and would make a cool nightgown. No. No it wouldn’t.
Heidi sends the designers away so the judges can talk.
First, their favorites. Ra’Mon’s was safe, but beautifully made. Nina thinks he needs more confidence. Johnny’s dress was a great shape, but needs a different color and better styling. Heidi would wear Christopher’s, and thinks it had youth to it.
Then the least favorites. Qristyl with a Q’s was a nightmare in the front, and Kors is nervous about her taste level. Oh, taste level. I’ve missed you.
They don’t know if Ari is serious at all, and think that speaking to her was like speaking to someone in another world. Lindsay Lohan cracks up at this for some reason, which reminds us that in addition to being an excellent judge, she’s totally young and adorable. Kors says she’s one of those designers whose work is so conceptual it forces you to wonder if you’re not smart enough to get it. Dude, no. Bitch be crazy, that’s all there is.
Mitchell’s dress was a “fully transparent nightgown caftan” that no one could wear. They’ve reached a decision. The designers are brought back out and told that one of them will be named the winner. . .and one will be OUWT. Commercial!
Does the world really need
more Sherri Shepherd?

Back! Heidi tells Johnny he’s in. He leaves the runway. Christopher. . . .is the winner! Yay!!! He has immunity for the next challenge. He’s proud to have won even though he doesn’t have the education the others do.
DRINK!
Ra’Mon is in. Qristyl with a Q is in.
So it’s down to Mitchell’s naked model and Ari’s . . .thing. Mitchell is safe, thank goodness. I couldn’t lose his adorable face this early.

This means Ari is out. She’s fairly sanguine about it. I’ve always thought it might actually be easier to leave first than fourth or fifth—it’s disappointing, yes, but there’s less of an attachment, not just to the people but to the system of the show itself.
Next week: they’re creating a look for an actual celebrity! Whee!