
No Upper East Side
Just a quick "Aufweidersehn."
Amy's going home.
I know, I know – I’m awful. I’m the worst. I’m like twelve + hours later than usual with this ridiculousness, and I apologize.
But let me give you some context: the very first thing my notes from last night say is “I’ve got hiccups.” Underlined. At the top of the page. I had hiccups last night – strong, dreadful, abdominal workout type hiccups – for the first time in longer than I can even remember.
And I had them for probably the first 30 minutes of the show, because every time I tried to take 20 seconds to hold my breath, I’d get to 7 or so and someone would say something to crack me up. Because apparently
MAKING ME CONTINUE TO HAVE HICCUPS IS FREAKING HYSTERICAL to some people.
And then there’s the fact that between the hiccups and the usual wine related complications, my notes are all but completely illegible. I mean, I usually start out with my normal abysmal handwriting and devolve toward chicken scratches by the end of the episode. But last night I started with chicken scratches and devolved toward something that can only be described as “the fuck?” Seriously, I stared at “I’ve got hiccups” for two minutes wondering why I’d written down “I’ve good humps.” Which I do, in the l
ovely lady lumps in the back and in the front Fergie type way, but it seemed like an odd thing to take notes on.
I'ma git git git you drunk. Git that song stuck in yo' head after you've managed to avoid it for three years. Mah humps. Mah humps mah humps mah humps. Mah lovely lady lumps.
And for some reason, there’s chocolate on some of the pages.
So I needed to give myself some time to work on deciphering them. More time than my normal wake up at 5:15 and hit the shower by 7:30 schedule permits. Especially today, since that schedule was thrown off by the fact that I slept through my alarm.
But now we can get down to business. Or "bidness, if you prefer.
And the first order of bidness is to say that I was kind of shocked by last night’s outcome. I realize Amy hasn’t consistently shrouded herself in glory or anything, but she’s generally done well, with the exception of the occasional pair of fish pants or top with fur tits. And she did well enough early on that I actually expected her to go further than this.
But oh well. Shall we?
Morning! New York! Atlas apartments. In the ladies’ apartment, Amy says that being in the bottom 3 means she has to step it up. I hope she
Steps It Up 2: The Streets!
Maya frets about how she hasn’t won a challenge yet. She finds it “frustrating, fer sure” that everyone who’s still there has won a challenge except for her.

Runway! Heidi greets them and points out that there are only 8 left – half of them are gone. Yay, Heidi did a fraction!
She tells them that their next challenge, they want them to get into a
New York state of mind. I hope
William Joel got his royalties for that reference.
They go to the designers lounge to meet with Tim. He’s standing there with the world’s greatest pockmarked makeup artist, Collier Strong.
For this challenge, they’re using New York City as the point of departure for their design. They’ll go to one of four neighborhoods: Chinatown, the East Village, the Upper East Side, and Harlem.
Emilio feels like he has to win this challenge because he lives in New York, and if he doesn’t win, it’ll be a real disappointment for him and for his people.
Crickets.
His people? What people? African-Americans? New Yorkers? Self satisfied forty-something douchebags who still wear
Newsie caps?
Tim has
more exciting news: They’ll be working in teams of two.
With the looks this elicits from some of the designers, it’s a wonder the Lifetime sound department managed to resist using the sad trombone sound effect there. Instead, they went for the ominous half-of the
Law & Order “
CHON-
CHON!” crash of doom. So just one "
CHON" of doom. If you only use one "
CHON," you don't have to pay royalties to NBC/Universal/General Electric/Scheinhardt Wig Company/Kabletown.
I call bullshit on this whole teams thing, by the way. It’s way too late in the game for a teams challenge. There are only 8 of them left. You’re telling me there aren't 4 other historically and architecturally significant neighborhoods in New York they could’ve sent them out to? What about SoHo? Spanish Harlem? Inwood? TriBeCa? Morningside Heights? Chelsea? The Financial District? Little Italy? Yorkville? Washington Heights? Manhattanville?
And you’ll notice I’m not even suggesting that they –
GASP—
leave Manhattan and go somewhere in the other boroughs. I may be from the cultural wastelands West of the Mississippi, but I'm not
THAT gauche.
And if it’s that critical that they make two looks inspired by the neighborhood – which, again, bullshit – then give them a longer time to do it in, and have them make a two look mini-collection on their own. Since they’re at the halfway point now, they could even bring back the
aufed designers to be a spare set of hands.
Why am I not the producer on this show instead of that pregnant Teutonic moron? See how much better my ideas are?
Anyway. I digress. Emilio prays to god that he doesn’t get stuck with Mila. Mila clarifies that she’s not a huge fan of teams because you never know what you’re gonna get. Well, Mila, it seems like by this point in the competition, your fellow designers are pretty clear on the fact that if they’re paired with you, they’re going to get a big helping of bitchcakes.
Tim further explains that each team will be making 2 looks – one for day and one for evening – and that they’ll have a budget of $300.
Anthony, Amy, Emilio, and Jay are the team leaders. Jay worries that he’s going to get stuck with last choice.
Anthony chooses Maya. Amy chooses Jonathan. Emilio chooses Seth Aaron. Jay can’t believe he’s stuck with Mila. Mila says she never talks to Jay and doesn’t really like him. WAH-wah.
But they get first choice of neighborhood to make up for working with the dud no one wants. So they get the East Village; Emilio and Seth Aaron take Harlem; Amy and Jonathan take the Upper East Side; and Anthony and Maya get Chinatown.
Collier Strong then talks about how they’re going to use L’Oreal to blah blah blah, and Tim sends them off to their ‘hoods for 30 minutes of exploring and sketching.
In Harlem, Emilio is happy to be back in his own neighborhood. He tells Seth Aaron that “Harlem is about churches, liquor stores, and fried chicken spots.” That sounds like a really good neighborhood to be in. They meet a very snazzy grandma in tight jeans, and get inspired to do something with denim and mosaic depicting jazz musicians.

In Chinatown, Anthony and Maya are thinking about structure and the color red. Maya’s glad Anthony chose her because they’re having fun and he’s making her laugh. They get freaked out by some ducks in a butcher window, but inspired by ladders and a paper dragon.
Jonathan tells us that the Upper East side has a feeling of high end and luxury. They think the architecture is very static, and worry that it won’t go with Amy’s style. They come up with the idea of a shirt dress for day, and a cut-away technique on the evening look to mimic wrought iron.
In the East Village, Mila and Jay try to get past their dislike of each other, and are drawn to the graffiti and industrial textures. Jay wants to do super elaborate pants. Mila finds Jay scattered and hopes they can get through it.

Mood! Fabric flurry! Jonathan and Amy are stumped by fabric shopping and find that agreeing on fabric cuts their time. Emilio and Seth Aaron find denims. Maya is worried about Anthony’s textile choices. Thank you Mood!
Workroom. Tim tells them they have until midnight tonight and precious little time tomorrow, and that they shouldn’t assume that the leader will go home.
Sketching. Mila doesn’t like what Jay’s doing for the day look, but he’s the leader and she’s letting him make the decisions. Emilio is going for a Cotton Club/Billie Holiday vibe with the evening look. Anthony thinks Maya has control issues, and she admits this. Jonathan and Amy are doing works with a lot of detail.
Commercial!
Under the line I draw to signify commercial breaks, it once again says
I HAVE HICCUPS. This time, it's in all caps, and it looks like looks like
I HAVE HKRAPS.
Back! Maya is working on the day look and Anthony is doing the evening look, which will have a 3-D diamond inspired by the dragon lantern. Maya is butting in on the evening look, and not focusing on her own. Anthony says she told him “’I’m just concerned about these looks ‘cause I’m such an artist,’ but it’s kinda like at this point, everybody on this show is an artist.”
Seth Aaron and Emilio try to find a middle ground in their very different working styles. Jay and Mila just don’t speak to each other. Mila says this is pretty normal for them because they just get in the Zone, and Jay thinks they’re being professional even though they don’t like each other.
Jonathan thinks that both he and Amy are detail oriented, which makes things take a long time.
Then Collier Strong comes in and whores his drugstore make-up to them.

Tim thru! He’s crazy about the jacket on Seth Anthony and Emilio’s day look. He thinks the jacket textile looks weak on Anthony and Maya’s day look. He’s concerned about Jay’s weird pants, and especially that they’re still debating the silhouette for their day look. He thinks Jonathan and Amy might be at risk of overdesigning.
5 hours left! Jonathan and Amy continue to worry about the overdesigned comment, and Jonathan thinks “he’s right; this could be a carnival.”
Anthony says “the problem that Anthony is running into is that the details on the evening dress are all completely hand stitched.” The problem that Jordan is running into is that it’s hard to like Anthony when he refers to himself in the third person.
Models! Jay tells his model, Britney, that he’s nervous, and she tells him she’s been praying there wouldn’t be team challenges. Weird. Seth Aaron runs into a problem with his jacket sleeves, so he cuts the cuffs off.
One and a half hours left! Mila is worried about the fact that Jay hasn’t started the tank top yet. Emilio does a cackle that's meant to be wicked and villainous, but is really just douchey, at the problems they’re having. Jonathan says that the two of them being a team was set up by Emilio because “he’s a naughty naughty naughty naughty boy.”
Jonathan and Amy are struggling with time, and Jonathan’s cutwork is getting sloppier as time goes on. Commercial!
Back! Day of show! Emilio asks Jonathan how he feels this morning, and Jonathan replies “disgusted.”
Mila says she’s hurting this morning. No idea why. Anthony’s apartment does their “we shall leave as three an’ return as three” thing. It would be less ominous seeming if we hadn't seen it for the first time last week, when they left as four and returned as. . .three.

Workroom! Maya is worried about the evening look being mostly black. Tim comes in and tells them they have an hour to do their product placement nonsense.
Models enter. Anthony worries that the daytime look looks a little evening. Mila thinks her outfit looks great, but can’t believe how bad Jay’s tank top is. Emilio wonders “what the hell is Amy and Jonathan building in that corner?” and doesn’t think they’ll be able to finish.
Hair and makeup flurry! 30 minutes to show! Amy runs around frantically. Mila doesn’t want to have to place blame, but she’s going to make sure the judges know what she’s done. Jay worries that she’s going to throw him under the bus. Jay is suddenly very perceptive.
Amy and Jonathan are sewing and trimming up to the absolute last moment. Commercial!
Back! Heidi enters in her most whorish maternity dress yet – it’s transparent, skin tight, and kind of zebra striped. Then she reminds them of the challenge, and introduces the judges:
Francisco Costa sitting in for Kors; Nina; and
Molly Sims.
Show! Lorena opens in Maya and Anthony’s day look which is a striped jacket and black skirt with pops of red. Monique wears their night look—a black cocktail dress with gold origami down it.
Jay’s day look is some weird riding breeches and a jiggly boob tank. Mila’s day look is another of her typical black and white “Mod” thing, but I like it better than most of her typical black and white “Mod” things. It doesn’t make her less of a one trick pony, though, and the red tights are doing all the work of the outfit.

Amy’s day look is a butterscotch ploufy top with black Capri pants. Jonathan’s evening dress is skin tight and suggests transparency, and is covered with. . . really interesting cut work. Our initial reaction to the dress was “That is HOT!” and it is. . .from a distance. It’s a fantastic idea, and if it’d been executed well it would’ve been amazing. But when you see stills of the dress, it’s really kind of sloppily done.

Seth Aaron’s day look is cute, but it’s very much the same denim jacket and pants he’s been making the whole time, and it’s topped off with this ridiculous poofy beret that gives it a very
Toujours Paris look. Emilio’s evening look is a long, shape conscious black gown with a beautiful yellow lining and zipper accents.
Heidi calls Jay and Mila and Amy and Jonathan, and tells them they have the lowest scores. They want to talk to the good teams first, so they send them away.
Beginning with Seth Aaron and Emilio, Heidi is in love with both pieces. Franco Costa felt that both are sophisticated. Emilio gives Seth Aaron props on being really strong in denim. Nina thinks they balanced each other well, but thinks Seth Aaron’s look would be more sophisticated with less detail – the coat has the exaggerated collar, piping, buttons, and tails. It is all a little much. Molly Sims says the typical useless model shit about loving it.
Moving to Anthony and Maya, Nina thinks it’s a great collaboration, and likes the little details in red on the day look and the origami on the evening look. Heidi can see a dragon in the work he’s done. Um, ‘kay. Molly Sims says useless bullshit about loving it.
Heidi asks how working with Maya was. Anthony says he was worried about working with her because she’s quiet, but “don’t let that pretty little face fool you: if she doesn’t like something or she wants to change something, she will surely let you know.”
The bad teams come out. Amy explains their team’s inspiration. Nina’s problem with the daywear look is that it’s not polished. Molly Sims uselessly agrees. Heidi calls it an eyesore and “quite ugly to be honest.” She says the night time look isn’t as bad, but it’s busy. Costa says it’s more sophisticated and has more workmanship. Nina likes the work in front, but hates the

panels.
Nina loves Mila’s nighttime look, especially the red hose. Ha. That's because they're doing
ALL THE WORK OF THE OUTFIT. But she’s very disappointed with the day look “it’s a taaaaaaaaaaank top,” she says. Heidi accuses Brittney’s boobs of “just kind of floating around in there.”

Molly Sims says “the tank is. . .no.” Useless. What a dimwit. Jay helps her out. “It tanked,” he says. She takes the cue. “The tank tanked," she says, trying to seem wise, hoping with all her might that the editors with their editing magic will make it look as though she thought that up all by herself. Then she wonders what an editor is, and if it's anything like a bunny. Or a leprechaun. She almost starts to hope that it might be like the beautiful, magical child of a bunny and a leprechaun, and then she realizes that that might be a little scary, actually. Then she thinks about what animals might have good children with leprechauns, or bunnies, or tiny little piglets, and how pretty her hair is, and how she should maybe get a puppy, and she wonders why Heidi has gotten so fat lately, and what she was talking about with that "there are eight of you, but soon there will be seven" nonsense earlier. Everyone knows that nine comes after eight. And besides, you shouldn't do math. It makes you think too hard, and then you get wrinkles in your forehead and by the sides of your mouth, like the mean Spanish lady she's sitting next to. (She thinks she's Spanish. Her last name is Garcia, which is the same as Molly's gardener. Maybe she is Molly's gardener's wife, or sister. Maybe she could clean Molly's house or something)
And then we are yanked out of the beautiful, vacant world inside Molly Sims' head, and back into the world of the runway.
Deliberation! Nina had had high hopes for Amy, but thinks she gets too caught up in the details and misses the big picture. Hedi thought the night look was better, but overworked.
On Jay and Mila, Heidi had a problem with the day look. Nina thought the pants were overworked. Heidi feels like Mila took over the team’s work. They think her execution was good.
For the good teams, Nina says that Anthony’s look had subtle and gentle sophistication. Molly uselessly says she’d wear the jacket from the day look. Then she asks Nina what her rate would be for a three bedroom, twice a week, and Nina gives her a look that would whither her soul, if there were any soul in there to whither. Molly thinks about the bunnies and leprechauns, and hope they make her look insightful when they put this episode together.
Heidi thinks Seth Aaron and Emilio had great pieces. Nina liked the injections of color. Franco Costa thinks they worked together well. Nina was disappointed in the evening dress because she knows Emilio can do more. Anyway they’ve reached a decision. Commercial!

Back! Right off the bat, Heidi tells Emilio he’s the winner. And Seth Aaron is. . . .also the winner! They hug. Seth Aaron says a double win is a
Project Runway first. Emilio is happy, and laughs his douche villain laugh.
Anthony and Maya are in. Mila and Jonathan are in.
So it’s down to Jay and Amy. Jay’s tank top was ill fitting and mismatched with the pants. Amy’s strange shirt dress was a disappointment, and bad Retro.

Amy is. . . out. Aw. Jay and his little tennis shorts leave the runway as Amy thanks the judges. Amy is proud of how far she’s come.
Jonathan says it’s really hard to watch Amy go home. And he cries. Tim tells her she’s incredibly talented, and they love her. AW.
Next time! You’ll be doing something every designer dreams about but seldom realizes. Looks of fear! Now or never! His taste is questionable! Not listening to Tim! Too conceptual! Disco Straightjacket!